| Nebula Award Novel Winner | | The Forever War | | 1975 |
| Ditmar Award Best International Long Fiction Winner | | The Forever War | | 1976 |
| Hugo Award Best Novel Winner | | The Forever War | | 1976 |
| Locus Poll Award Best SF Novel | | The Forever War | | 1976 |
| Nebula Award Short Story Nomination | | Tricentennial | | 1976 |
| Hugo Award Best Novel Nomination | | Mindbridge | | 1977 |
| Hugo Award Best Short Story Winner | | Tricentennial | | 1977 |
| Rhysling Award Long Poem Winner | | Saul's Death | | 1984 |
| Nebula Award Short Story Nomination | | More Than the Sum of His Parts | | 1985 |
| Prometheus Award Hall of Fame Award for Best Classic Libertarian SF Novel Nomination | | The Forever War | | 1987 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | The Gift | | 1988 |
| Nebula Award Novella Winner | | The Hemingway Hoax | | 1990 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Novella Nomination | | The Hemingway Hoax | | 1991 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Astrology Column | | 1991 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | The Star: From and for Arthur C. Clarke | | 1991 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | The Cepheid Variable | | 1991 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Eighteen Years Old, October Eleventh | | 1991 |
| SF Chronicle Award Novella Nomination | | The Hemingway Hoax | | 1991 |
| Hugo Award Best Novella | | The Hemingway Hoax | | 1991 |
| Rhysling Award Short Poem Winner | | Eighteen Years Old, October Eleventh | | 1991 |
| World Fantasy Award Best Novella Nomination | | The Hemingway Hoax | | 1991 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | The SF Editor's Lament | | 1992 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Carbon Star | | 1992 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | The Number of the Man | | 1992 |
| Nebula Award Short Story Winner | | Graves | | 1993 |
| World Fantasy Award Best Short Fiction Winner | | Graves | | 1993 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Solo | | 1994 |
| Homer Award Short Story Winner | | None So Blind | | 1994 |
| Nebula Award Short Story Nomination | | None So Blind | | 1994 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Short Story Nomination | | None So Blind | | 1995 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Big Boom | | 1995 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Waiting to Explode | | 1995 |
| SF Chronicle Award Short Story Winner | | None So Blind | | 1995 |
| Hugo Award Best Short Story Winner | | None So Blind | | 1995 |
| Skylark Award Edward E. Smith Memorial Award for Imaginative Fiction Winner | | | | 1996 |
| John W. Campbell Award John W. Campbell Memorial Award Winner | | Forever Peace | | 1998 |
| Hugo Award Best Novel Winner | | Forever Peace | | 1998 |
| Nebula Award Novel Winner | | Forever Peace | | 1998 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Dog Star | | 2000 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Dying Live on CNN | | 2001 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Nomination | | Fire on Ice | | 2001 |
| Rhysling Award Long Poem Winner | | January Fires | | 2001 |
| Asimov's Readers' Poll Asimov's Reader's Poll Poem Winner | | January Fires | | 2002 |